"But if they don't donate, who cares!"
See three priests' thoughts below.
Priest #1
"Left in the vestibule and at each of the exits, people will pick them up and usually leave a donation. But if they don't, who cares! We're interested in souls. If there are concerns about expenses, don't worry; with one CD-listening convert or one lapsed Catholic who returns "home" we would probably cover most of our costs in the first few Sunday collections!" - Rev. Francis Peffley (taken from 30 Ways to Sanctify, Evangelize and Catechize a Parish by Rev. Francis J. Peffley)
Priest #2
A priest, new to Lighthouse, was concerned about the Lighthouse apostolate and if it would bring in money to cover the program. The very next time he saw his volunteer, instead of the hesitation, he was enthusiastic and wanted more CDs. The difference? "We've saved a soul!" he said. While he couldn't share the details, he did share that a parishioner had come to confession after many years away....and it was a Lighthouse CD that had brought him to the confessional. The priest then added, "The cost doesn't matter...we are going to save souls!"
Priest #3
Hear Fr. David Richter's wisdom in an interview (approx. 20 min.), some of the questions pertaining to donations, by clicking here.
When we recognize we've received a gift, there is a desire to be more generous, not only with our finances, but also with our time and our presence...
I haven't been worried about finances... I've trusted that the CDs are good, not only for me but for my people... Whether it costs us a few dollars or not, it's still worth doing.
My own confession...When people are generous to me at Christmas or birthdays, I'll put a hundred dollars in the CD box so that I can stand up there and say, "Look, I'll cover your costs of the CDs if you'll listen to them. And if you feel you've received something, just be generous in return so that we can get more..."
(When asked what he'd say if a priest worries about selling CDs, Father replied...) Make it a part of your budget to feed your parishioners with these CDs, so you don't have to worry about selling them. I think a big part is trusting God. If I believe that this is what's good for my people, I'm going to do it even if it costs the parish some... The chances of them giving are far better if they listen to them than if they don't listen to them... I tell them, "Listen to them and then respond with what you've received."
I tell them, "We pay for the CDs whether you use them or not, so the only tragedy is if you don't listen to them."